Three Concentrations of St. John's Wort Effective Against Depression
At least 25 double-blind clinical studies have established the
efficacy of St. John's wort (Hypericum perforatum L., Clusiaceae)
in treating mild-to-moderate depression. In a recent double-blind,
multicenter study, Swiss researchers took off in a different direction.
They attempted to determine the optimum dosage of hypericin, a
constituent that is thought to play an important role in the plant's
antidepressant activity (Lenoir et al., 1999). Researchers compared
the effect of three different concentrations of St. John's wort
(SJW) in 348 depressed individuals over a six-week period. The
study included the concentration used in clinical studies and
commercial products (0.33 mg total hypericin per day), as well
as extracts with lower and higher hypericin content. At the end
of the trial, all three treatment groups demonstrated significant
improvement, with no major differences between the groups. Researchers
did not measure the effects of other potentially important compounds
in the SJW extracts, such as hyperforin.
Volunteers for the study were recruited from 38 centers in Germany
and Switzerland. Participants took three tablets of SJW daily
(Hyperiforce, manufactured by Bioforce AG, Switzerland), standardized
to either 0.17 mg, 0.33 mg, or 1 mg total hypericin per day. The
range of hypericin tested in the study was based on monographs
published by Germany's Commission E and the European Scientific
Cooperative for Phytotherapy (ESCOP), which recommend a range
of 0.2 mg to 1.0 mg of hypericin daily. This study did not include
a placebo group, both for ethical reasons and because previous
placebo-controlled studies have established the plant's overall
efficacy. Researchers measured improvement using the Hamilton
Psychiatric Rating Scale for Depression (HAMD-17), self-assessments
from patients (Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale), and physician
assessments (Clinical Global Impression Scale).
At the end of the six-week study, HAMD scores decreased to a
significant degree, by roughly 50 percent in all three treatment
groups with little difference between dose levels. The HAMD measures
a reduction in symptoms such as depressive mood, insomnia, fatigue,
anxiety, and inability to perform daily tasks. Physicians rated
the efficacy of SJW "moderate to good" in roughly 70
percent of cases for all of the groups. Self-assessments by patients
supported these results. Seventy-four patients reported a total
of 82 mild side effects during the course of the study; however,
only seven were causally linked to SJW. The most common complaints
were nausea, headache, and dizziness, and there was no difference
in the overall incidence between groups. There were 88 dropouts
from the study due to lack of compliance, medical reasons, or
other causes.
The overall response rate in this study was 62 to 68 percent,
which is higher than the average 55 percent response rate the
authors found in the 13 placebo-controlled studies they analyzed
for their study. The authors suggested that their results might
be due to the specific extract used in this study - a preparation
made from the fresh tips of SJW shoots, which are thought to yield
a higher concentration of hypericin than whole plant extracts.
On the other hand, the study only considered hypericin content,
leaving many unanswered questions about the range of different
compounds that may be important to SJW's antidepressant activity.
The lack of a dose-response effect in this trial with SJW standardized
for hypericin content may provide support for the theory that
hypericin is not the main active constituent for the relief of
mild-to-moderate depression. - Krista Morien, HRF
[Lenoir S, Degenring FH, Saller R. A double-blind randomised
trial to investigate three different concentrations of a standardised
fresh plant extract obtained from the shoot tips of Hypericum
perforatum L. Phytomedicine 1999; 6(3): 141-146.]
|
